Fragrance-Free Moisturizer: What to Check and Where a Plain Oil Fits

A fragrance-free moisturizer is one with no fragrance ingredient added, and dermatologists treat that label differently from “unscented.” This guide covers what fragrance-free means on a moisturizer, which form (lotion, cream or ointment) the American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) suggests for dry skin, what to check on the label, and where a single-ingredient oil fits and where it does not.

For the wider label guide, see our complete guide to what fragrance-free means.

What Does Fragrance-Free Mean on a Moisturizer?

It means no fragrance ingredient has been added, and it is a different claim from “unscented.” In its dry-skin tips, the AAD says dermatologists recommend products labelled “fragrance-free,” and that a product labelled “unscented” can contain chemicals that neutralize or hide the odours of other ingredients. Those chemicals, the AAD adds, can irritate dry, sensitive skin.

The AAD's page on testing skin care products makes the same point from the other side: products labelled “unscented,” or that have plant-based botanical ingredients, may still have fragrance-related ingredients. In the AAD's moisturizer guide, dermatologist Rebecca Kazin, MD, puts it bluntly: “all natural in no way means hypoallergenic.”

In practice, look for “fragrance-free” on the front of the pack and check that the word “fragrance” (or “parfum”) does not appear on the ingredient list, rather than trusting “unscented” or “natural.”

Which Form Suits Your Skin: Lotion, Cream or Ointment?

For dry skin, the AAD's dermatologists point to a cream or an ointment rather than a lotion. The AAD moisturizer guide describes the four forms like this:

• Gel: often water-based and lighter on the skin than a lotion.
• Lotion: lighter than a cream. One dermatologist in the guide says a lotion is sufficient for most younger people with otherwise-normal skin and seasonal dryness.
• Cream: thicker and higher in oil content than a lotion or gel, which makes it more hydrating. One dermatologist says perimenopausal people and everyone 50 and older should use a cream-based moisturizer.
• Ointment: the thickest form and, according to the guide, the most effective for dry skin.

For oily skin, the guide notes that too much moisturizer can clog pores in some people and suggests considering skipping it or choosing a gel. For combination skin, one dermatologist advises moisturizing the dry spots and skipping the oily areas.

Which Fragrance-Free Moisturizer Is Best for Dry or Sensitive Skin?

The AAD does not name a best product. Its dermatologists say to start with a fragrance-free cream or ointment for dry skin, then check the label for these four things:

• Fragrance-free on the front, no fragrance on the list: the AAD advises avoiding fragrance, which can irritate dry skin.
• Non-comedogenic: the AAD says to choose a moisturizer labelled non-comedogenic, meaning it does not block pores.
• No alcohol or alpha-hydroxy acids (AHAs): the guide says to avoid products with alcohol, AHA and fragrance to help your skin keep its natural oils.
• Ceramides and hyaluronic acid: two examples of ingredients Dr. Kazin says to look for. Ceramides are waxy lipid molecules that help hydrate skin, and hyaluronic acid is known for intense moisturizing.

Apply it right after you get out of the shower, while your skin is still damp, and pick one you are comfortable using at least twice a day, the guide says. The AAD's dry-skin tips add that you should reapply after washing your hands and whenever your skin feels dry.

Where Does a Plain Oil Fit Next to a Moisturizer?

A plain oil is an optional extra here, not a substitute that any AAD page we read backs. The three AAD pages we read never mention face oils. The two about moisturizers discuss lotions, gels, creams and ointments, so we have no dermatology source comparing an oil with a cream.

What a single-ingredient oil does give you is an easy label check. Our Argan Oil Pipette (Blue Label) is described on its product page as 100% pure cold-pressed argan oil with no fillers, fragrance or preservatives, and our Pure Jojoba Oil as 100% pure jojoba seed oil with no refining, deodorizing or blending. The jojoba page describes its golden colour and faint nutty scent as markers of first-press extraction.

A faint natural smell is not the same as an added fragrance, so judge by the ingredient list rather than your nose. Because the AAD advises testing any new skin care product, test an oil the same way (steps below). If your skin is very dry, red or cracking, the AAD guidance above points to a cream or ointment first, so ask a dermatologist before relying on an oil.

How Do You Test a New Moisturizer Before Using It Everywhere?

Test it on a small spot for seven to 10 days first, as the AAD's dermatologists recommend. Here is the method:

1. Choose a test spot: Pick a quarter-sized spot where the product won't be rubbed or washed away, such as the underside of your arm or the bend of your elbow.
2. Apply twice daily: Use the normal amount and thickness you would use regularly, twice a day for seven to 10 days, and leave it on as long as you normally would.
3. Check the result: If you have no red, itchy or swollen skin after seven to 10 days, go ahead and use the product.
4. Stop if you react: Gently wash the product off as soon as possible and don't use it again. The AAD says a cool compress or petroleum jelly can relieve your skin.
5. Get help if it is severe: If the reaction is severe, or you can't tell which ingredient caused it, talk to a board-certified dermatologist, who can help find the cause, which may involve patch testing.

When Is Dry Skin Worth a Dermatologist Visit?

Dry skin that a fragrance-free moisturizer does not settle is worth a professional look. The AAD says skin that is red, cracking, itching, stinging or has a rash may be excessively dry. See a dermatologist if:

• Dryness gets worse or becomes painful, cracked, bleeding, stinging or very irritating
• A moisturizer you use at least twice a day does not help
• You react to a product and cannot tell which ingredient caused it

Our Fragrance-Free Skincare guide covers how to switch your routine one product at a time.

This content is for informational purposes only and is not medical advice. Individual results may vary.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is unscented moisturizer the same as fragrance-free?

No. The AAD says a product labelled “unscented” can contain chemicals that neutralize or hide odours, and those chemicals can irritate dry, sensitive skin. It recommends products labelled “fragrance-free.”

Is a natural moisturizer automatically hypoallergenic?

No. Dermatologist Rebecca Kazin, MD, says in the AAD's moisturizer guide that “all natural in no way means hypoallergenic.” The AAD also says products with plant-based botanical ingredients may still contain fragrance-related ingredients.

Should I moisturize while my skin is still damp?

Yes. The AAD's dermatologists say to apply moisturizer right after a shower or bath, while skin is still damp, because thicker creams and ointments spread more easily and trap water in the skin.

How often should I moisturize dry skin?

The AAD's dry-skin tips say to apply moisturizer several times a day, including after washing your hands, and its moisturizer guide suggests choosing one you are comfortable using at least twice a day.

Does fragrance-free mean it won't irritate my skin?

No. Fragrance-free removes one possible irritant, but other ingredients can still irritate, which is why the AAD recommends testing a new product on a small spot for seven to 10 days before using it widely.

Related Articles