The short answer: both types can protect you if the label says broad spectrum, SPF 30 or higher and water resistant. The real differences are the active ingredients, how they feel on skin and who they suit. This guide sets out what Health Canada and the American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) say, including where they differ.
We sell a Green Beaver mineral sunscreen cream, so read this with that in mind. The comparison comes from the two sources linked below; our own products are covered in one section.
Mineral sunscreens use zinc oxide or titanium dioxide as the active ingredient. Chemical sunscreens use filters such as avobenzone, octocrylene or oxybenzone. Hybrid products contain both kinds.
The AAD says either type protects well if it is broad spectrum, SPF 30 or higher and water resistant. The choice comes down to skin, feel and personal preference.
For sensitive skin and children, the AAD recommends mineral sunscreens. Health Canada says side effects are rare and advises a 48-hour patch test on the inner forearm before using a new product.
Health Canada and the FDA say sunscreen absorption does not equal risk, and people should not stop using sunscreen. Both agencies say more research on absorbed ingredients is still needed.
What Is the Difference Between Mineral and Chemical Sunscreen?
The difference is the active ingredient. Health Canada says chemical filters absorb UV radiation and convert it into a small amount of heat, while physical (mineral) filters are believed to work by scattering and reflecting it.
- Chemical filters: Health Canada lists avobenzone, homosalate, octocrylene, octisalate, octinoxate and oxybenzone as examples.
- Mineral filters: Zinc oxide and titanium dioxide. Health Canada classifies them as natural ingredients.
- Hybrid: The AAD calls a sunscreen with one or more filters from both groups a hybrid.
- A small disagreement: Health Canada says mineral filters are believed to scatter and reflect UV. The AAD says they also absorb it, citing a 2016 study. Either way, both describe a layer that protects the skin.
How Can You Tell Which Type Your Sunscreen Is?
Read the active ingredients and the number on the label. The AAD says that if the active ingredient is titanium dioxide, zinc oxide or both, it is a mineral sunscreen; if neither is listed, it is chemical.
- Natural product number (NPN): Health Canada says products with only mineral filters carry an 8-digit NPN.
- Drug identification number (DIN): Products with any chemical filter, including hybrids, carry an 8-digit DIN.
- Active ingredients panel: The AAD says to look for the section labeled Active Ingredients.
Is Mineral or Chemical Sunscreen More Effective?
Neither type wins on its own. The AAD says any of them can protect effectively if it offers all three of these: SPF 30 or higher, broad-spectrum protection and water resistance.
- SPF: The AAD says SPF 15 filters out about 93% of UVB rays and SPF 30 about 97%, and that no sunscreen filters out all of them.
- Broad spectrum: Health Canada says it covers both UVA and UVB; UVB is the main cause of sunburn and both can raise skin cancer risk.
- Water resistance: The AAD says water resistant means 40 minutes on wet skin and very water resistant means 80 minutes.
Which Is Better for Sensitive Skin and Kids?
The AAD recommends mineral sunscreens for people with sensitive skin, and says sunscreens labelled for babies generally contain only zinc oxide, titanium dioxide or both. Health Canada adds that rare reactions can come from UV filters, fragrances or preservatives.
- Children 6 months and older: The AAD says to use a sunscreen with titanium dioxide or zinc oxide, and still to use shade and clothing.
- Babies under 6 months: The AAD says to keep them in the shade and covered, and to avoid sunscreen if possible. Health Canada says to ask your health care provider.
- Patch test: Health Canada says to test a new product on the inner forearm and check for a reaction after 48 hours.
Does Mineral Sunscreen Leave a White Cast?
Some do. The AAD says some sunscreens leave a white residue, and that a tinted sunscreen matching your skin tone can help avoid it.
- Tinted formulas: The AAD says tinted sunscreens contain iron oxide, which research shows helps protect against visible light, a concern for dark spots and melasma.
- Non-whitening labels: Some brands label products non-whitening. That is the maker's description, so judge it on your own skin.
Is Sunscreen Absorption a Concern?
Not enough is known yet, and the agencies say not to stop using sunscreen. Health Canada reviewed FDA studies showing some ingredients are absorbed into the blood, and agrees with the FDA that absorption does not equal risk.
- Still open: Health Canada says more information is needed to know whether absorbed ingredients pose a risk.
- AAD view: The AAD says that just because an ingredient is absorbed does not mean it is harmful, and that people should keep using sunscreen.
- Reef claims: The AAD says the evidence on sunscreen and reefs is limited and that the FDA has not defined the reef labels used on packaging, so we make no reef claim.
How Much Sunscreen Should You Use, and How Often?
About 7 teaspoons (35 mL) covers an adult's exposed skin, and you reapply at least every 2 hours. Health Canada gives that amount and says applying less greatly reduces the protection.
- Before going out: Apply at least 15 minutes ahead, generously and evenly.
- Reapply: At least every 2 hours, and more often after sweating, swimming or towelling off. The AAD says to reapply after the stated 40 or 80 minutes in water.
- Winter too: Health Canada says to protect skin even on cloudy days and in winter, since snow reflects UV rays.
- Storage: Do not leave it in a hot car; extreme heat can make it less effective. Check the expiry date too.
How Do You Choose a Sunscreen, Step by Step?
Check the three essentials, read the active ingredients, then match the formula to your skin. These steps combine the points Health Canada and the AAD share.
- Check the three essentials: Broad spectrum, SPF 30 or higher and water resistant.
- Read the active ingredients: Zinc oxide or titanium dioxide means mineral; anything else listed means chemical or hybrid.
- Match your skin: Choose mineral for sensitive skin or children over 6 months; consider a tint to avoid white residue.
- Patch test: Try it on the inner forearm and check after 48 hours.
- Apply enough, and reapply: About 35 mL for the body, every 2 hours or after water or sweat.
Featured in this guide
Green Beaver Mineral Sunscreen Cream, SPF 40 Sport
Zinc oxide 8% and titanium dioxide 8%, SPF 40, labelled water resistant for 80 minutes, 90 mL tube.
Shop now → ✓ 30-day money-back guarantee · Free shipping over $75Which Mineral Sunscreens Do We Sell?
We sell two Green Beaver mineral sunscreens. The SPF 40 Sport cream lists zinc oxide 8% and titanium dioxide 8% as its active ingredients and is labelled water resistant for 80 minutes.
- Cream, SPF 40: It meets the three essentials above on its label: SPF 30 or higher, UVA and UVB, and water resistance.
- Spray, SPF 27: The Green Beaver mineral spray lists zinc oxide 24% as its only active ingredient. At SPF 27 it is below the AAD's SPF 30 line, so pick the cream if you want to meet it.
- Size: Each is a 90 mL pack, enough for about two and a half full-body applications at Health Canada's 35 mL guide.
- What we do not claim: We do not claim any sunscreen is better for the environment, or that mineral beats chemical for everyone.
Should You Talk to a Professional Before Choosing?
Yes, if you have a skin condition, a history of reactions or a baby under 6 months. Health Canada says to speak to a health care provider if you are unsure which product is right or have questions about a reaction.
- Reactions: Health Canada says that if a rash or itching appears, try a different type or brand.
- Skin checks: A board-certified dermatologist can answer sunscreen questions, according to the AAD.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is mineral sunscreen better than chemical sunscreen?
Not for everyone. The AAD says either type protects effectively if it is broad spectrum, SPF 30 or higher and water resistant, and recommends mineral for sensitive skin.
What are the active ingredients in mineral sunscreen?
Zinc oxide, titanium dioxide or both. Health Canada classifies them as natural ingredients and says products with only these carry an NPN.
Is mineral sunscreen good for kids?
The AAD says children 6 months and older should use a sunscreen with titanium dioxide or zinc oxide, along with shade and clothing.
How often should you reapply sunscreen?
Health Canada says at least every 2 hours, and more often after sweating, swimming or towelling off.
Do you need sunscreen in winter?
Health Canada says to protect your skin even on cloudy days and in winter, because snow reflects UV rays.
Shop Green Beaver Mineral Sunscreen — 30-Day Guarantee